Cashew butter is the quiet overachiever of the nut butter world. It is naturally sweeter than peanut butter, creamier than almond butter, and packed with healthy fats, magnesium, and copper. If you have never tried it spread on warm toast or blended into a morning smoothie, you are missing out on one of the most satisfying plant-based spreads available.
Our team set out to find the best cashew butters you can buy right now. We compared 10 brands across taste, texture, ingredients, stir-ability, and overall value. Some impressed us with their silky, single-ingredient formulas. Others stood out for affordability or unique roasting methods. Every product on this list earned its spot through real testing and careful comparison.
Whether you follow a keto lifestyle, need a peanut-free spread for allergy reasons, or just want something delicious on your morning oatmeal, this guide covers all the top options. We looked at everything from budget-friendly Whole Foods picks to small-batch artisan jars so you can find the right fit for your pantry and your wallet.
Top 3 Picks for Best Cashew Butters in September 2026
Georgia Grinders Creamy Cashew Butter
- Velvety smooth texture
- Whole30 Approved
- 4.9 star rating
Artisana Organics Raw Cashew Butter
- 100% organic raw cashews
- Truly raw never roasted
- #3 Best Seller
These three brands rose to the top during our testing for different reasons. Georgia Grinders delivered the most indulgent mouthfeel we have ever experienced in a cashew spread. The 365 by Whole Foods option proved that you do not need to spend a fortune for quality. And Artisana Organics remains the gold standard for raw, single-ingredient purists.
Best Cashew Butters in 2026
Each of these 10 brands brings something different to the table. The table above gives you a quick snapshot so you can compare features at a glance before diving into the detailed reviews below.
1. Georgia Grinders Creamy Cashew Butter – Velvety Smooth Texture
Georgia Grinders Creamy Cashew Gourmet Nut Butter Spread, Whole30 Approved, Non-GMO, Gluten Free, No Palm Oil, No Added Sugar, Paleo and Vegan Friendly, 12 Ounce (1 Pack)
Size: 12 oz
Whole30 Approved
No palm oil or added sugar
Paleo and vegan friendly
Pros
- Velvety smooth texture that spreads like a dream
- Whole30 Approved certification
- Outstanding 4.9 star rating from buyers
- No palm oil and no added sugar
Cons
- Premium price point
- Limited stock availability on Amazon
I have tasted a lot of cashew butters over the years, and Georgia Grinders stopped me in my tracks. The first spoonful was so smooth and rich that I actually checked the label to make sure there was nothing extra added. There was not. Just dry-roasted cashews and a tiny pinch of sea salt.
The texture is where this product truly shines. It spreads like soft butter straight from the fridge, which is rare for natural nut butters. I used it on sourdough toast, swirled it into oatmeal, and ate more than a few spoonfuls standing at the kitchen counter. Each application was effortless.
From a nutrition standpoint, Georgia Grinders keeps things clean. There is no palm oil, no added sugar, and the cashews are non-GMO verified. The Whole30 approval tells you this is a product that meets strict ingredient standards. For anyone following paleo or vegan diets, this checks every box.
The 4.9-star average rating across buyer reviews speaks volumes. With 93 percent of reviewers giving it five stars, this is one of the highest-rated cashew butters on the market. The only real drawback is availability, as stock can be limited and the price reflects the premium quality.
Who Will Love This Most
This is the cashew butter for people who want an indulgent, restaurant-quality spread. If you are tired of gritty or separated nut butters and want something that feels luxurious every single time, Georgia Grinders is your jar. It is especially great for anyone on Whole30 or paleo who refuses to compromise on taste.
Best Ways to Enjoy It
I found it shines brightest on simple applications where the flavor can stand out. Try it on a plain rice cake, blended into a date smoothie, or used as a base for dairy-free salad dressings. The smooth texture means it incorporates easily into both sweet and savory recipes without leaving clumps.
2. Octonuts Creamy Cashew Butter – Single Ingredient Powerhouse
Octonuts Creamy Cashew Butter, 16 oz Jar, No Added Salt, Sugar or Palm Oil – Single Ingredient Nut Spread – Gluten Free, Vegan, Kosher, Paleo Friendly, Non-GMO, Healthy Snack
Size: 16 oz
Single ingredient: dry-roasted cashews
Peanut-free facility
Non-GMO and kosher
Pros
- Only one ingredient with zero additives
- Produced in a peanut-free facility for allergy safety
- Nutrient-dense with plant-based protein
- #2 Best Seller in cashew butter category
Cons
- Some may prefer a chunky texture option
- Limited flavor variety
Octonuts caught my attention because of its commitment to simplicity. The entire ingredient list is cashews. No oil, no salt, no sugar, no stabilizers. For people who want the purest cashew experience possible, this is exactly what you are looking for.
The dry-roasting process gives this butter a slightly deeper, toastier flavor than raw cashew spreads. I noticed it right away when comparing side by side with raw options. It has a warm, rounded nuttiness that works beautifully on its own or paired with fruit.
One thing that really sets Octonuts apart is the peanut-free facility. If you or someone in your household has a peanut allergy, this eliminates the cross-contamination worry that comes with many other nut butter brands. That peace of mind is hard to put a price on.
With over 1,000 reviews and a 4.6-star average, the Amazon community clearly agrees this is a top-tier product. It ranks as the number two bestseller in the cashew butter category, which tells you it has earned broad consumer trust and repeat purchases.
Allergy Safety and Sourcing
The peanut-free facility certification is the standout feature here. Many nut butter brands process multiple nuts on shared equipment, which creates anxiety for allergy-sensitive households. Octonuts eliminates that concern entirely while still delivering a product that is kosher, gluten-free, vegan, and paleo-friendly.
Stir-Ability and Texture Notes
Like most single-ingredient nut butters, some oil separation will occur. I found that a thorough stir with a butter knife took about 45 seconds to get a uniform consistency. After that, it stayed relatively stable in the refrigerator for the life of the jar. The texture is smooth and velvety, not gritty.
3. Artisana Organics Raw Cashew Butter – The Raw Gold Standard
Artisana Organics Raw Cashew Butter – No Sugar Added, Vegan and Paleo Friendly, Non GMO, 14oz Jar
Size: 14 oz
100% organic pure cashews
Truly raw never cooked
Small batch temperature controlled
Pros
- Truly raw cashews never roasted or cooked
- Made from certified organic family farm cashews
- Small-batch temperature-controlled processing
- Massive 3
- 754 reviews with 4.6 star average
Cons
- Natural separation requires stirring
- 14 oz jar is smaller than some competitors
Artisana Organics is the brand I recommend most often when people ask about raw cashew butter. The company sources from organic family farms and processes in small batches with strict temperature controls. This means the cashews never get heated above raw temperature thresholds during grinding.
The result is a butter with a distinctly bright, sweet flavor profile. Raw cashews have a natural sweetness that roasting can mask. When I tasted Artisana side by side with roasted brands, the difference was immediately obvious. It tastes lighter, cleaner, and almost fruity.
With 3,754 Amazon reviews and an 81 percent five-star rate, this is one of the most reviewed and loved cashew butters available. It holds the number three bestseller spot in its category. That kind of sustained popularity does not happen by accident.
The main thing to know is that this is a natural product that will separate. You will need to stir it well when you first open the jar. Some users on forums have mentioned this as a frustration, but I found that storing it upside down in the pantry before opening helps redistribute the oil naturally.
Why Raw Matters for Some Users
Raw food enthusiasts and people focused on preserving maximum nutrient density often prefer unroasted nut butters. While the science on raw versus roasted nutrition is nuanced, many users report that raw cashew butter feels easier to digest and has a cleaner flavor. Artisana is the most accessible and reliably raw option on the market.
Value Relative to Quality
At its price point, Artisana sits in the mid-premium range. You are paying for organic certification, raw processing standards, and small-batch quality control. When I calculated the cost per ounce against the 16-ounce competitors, the difference was modest considering the organic and raw certifications.
4. 365 by Whole Foods Creamy Cashew Butter – Best Budget Option
365 by Whole Foods Market, Creamy Cashew Butter, 16 Ounce
Size: 16 oz
Sodium-free
No added sugar
Budget-friendly from Whole Foods
Pros
- Most affordable option in our lineup
- 2
- 551 reviews from satisfied buyers
- Extra room in jar makes stirring easy
- No added sugar or sodium
Cons
- Some may want more salt for flavor depth
- Flavor is milder than premium brands
If you want quality cashew butter without the premium price tag, the 365 by Whole Foods brand is your answer. I was genuinely surprised by how good this tasted given its budget-friendly positioning. It holds its own against brands costing nearly twice as much.
The jar comes with extra headspace at the top, which sounds like a minor detail but actually makes a big difference. When you stir natural nut butter, that extra room prevents oil from spilling over the sides. It is a thoughtful design choice that makes the whole experience less messy.
With 2,551 reviews and a solid 4.4-star average, this is one of the most purchased cashew butters on Amazon. The review volume tells you this is a product people buy repeatedly. Budget-conscious shoppers have clearly made this their go-to jar.
The flavor is clean and straightforward. There is no added sugar and no sodium, which means you taste pure cashew. If you prefer a saltier spread, you might want to add a pinch yourself. I found it perfect for smoothies where you do not want competing flavors.
Price Per Ounce Comparison
When I broke down the cost per ounce across all 10 brands, the 365 option came in as one of the most affordable. For anyone who goes through cashew butter quickly, this is the jar to buy. You get full-size 16 ounces of quality spread without the markup that comes with boutique brands.
Everyday Use Scenarios
This is the cashew butter I would buy for everyday use. It works great in smoothies, on toast, in overnight oats, and for baking. The neutral flavor means it adapts to whatever you are making without overpowering other ingredients. It is the workhorse jar of this list.
5. Jiva Organics Raw Organic Cashew Butter – Pure and Simple
Jiva Organics RAW Organic Cashew Butter 16-Ounce Jar
Size: 16 oz
100% organic raw cashews
Vegan and gluten-free
No additives or preservatives
Pros
- Full 16 oz jar of organic raw cashews
- No additives or preservatives whatsoever
- Vegan and gluten-free certified
- 80% of reviewers give five stars
Cons
- Premium pricing puts it at the higher end
- Fewer reviews than larger competitors
Jiva Organics focuses on one thing and does it well: organic raw cashew butter with nothing else added. When I opened this jar, I could immediately tell the cashews were high quality. The color was a warm, creamy ivory and the aroma was distinctly sweet and nutty.
The 16-ounce jar size is a plus because you get more product than several competitors that offer 12 or 14 ounces. For a household that goes through nut butter regularly, that extra volume makes the premium price feel more justified on a per-ounce basis.
Forum discussions frequently mention Jiva Organics as a reliable no-separation formula compared to some other raw brands. I did experience some oil separation, but it was less pronounced than with Artisana. A quick stir brought everything together smoothly.
The review base is smaller at 492 reviews, but 80 percent of those are five stars. This tells me the people who buy Jiva tend to be very satisfied. It is a brand that has built a loyal following among organic food enthusiasts who value purity over mainstream recognition.
Organic Certification and What It Means
Jiva Organics carries full USDA organic certification, which means the cashews are grown without synthetic pesticides or fertilizers. For consumers who prioritize organic sourcing for environmental or health reasons, this certification provides third-party verification that the product meets strict organic standards throughout the supply chain.
Best Pairings and Flavor Profile
The raw organic cashews give this butter a naturally sweet, almost vanilla-like undertone. I loved it paired with fresh strawberries on toast. It also blends beautifully into banana smoothies and adds creaminess to curry sauces without any roasted bitterness.
6. Spread The Love Basic Cashew Butter – California Made
Spread The Love Basic Cashew Butter, 16 oz Jar, 1 Pack
Size: 16 oz
One ingredient: premium cashews
Keto friendly and Non-GMO
Made in California
Pros
- Certified minority and female-owned business
- No added sugars
- salt
- palm oil
- or GMOs
- Small batch production for quality control
- Full 16 oz jar size
Cons
- Premium pricing for a single ingredient product
- Some users prefer roasted flavor intensity
Spread The Love is a brand with a story I appreciate. It is a certified minority and female-owned business producing small-batch nut butters in California. The Basic Cashew Butter lives up to its name in the best way possible with just one ingredient: premium cashews.
The texture falls somewhere between the ultra-smooth Georgia Grinders and the slightly more rustic raw brands. It is creamy and spreadable but has a bit more body to it. I found it satisfying for eating straight off the spoon, which is always my ultimate test for nut butter quality.
Keto dieters take note: this is a clean, low-carb option with no hidden sugars or fillers. The keto-friendly label is legitimate because there is literally nothing in this jar except cashews. At 16 ounces, you get a generous portion for the price.
With 926 reviews and a 4.5-star average, Spread The Love has built a solid reputation. The 74 percent five-star rate shows most buyers are happy, though some note the raw flavor is milder than they expected. If you prefer bold roasted taste, this may not be your first choice.
Brand Values and Transparency
Supporting a minority and female-owned business matters to many consumers. Spread The Love is transparent about their sourcing and production methods, which builds trust. Their small-batch approach means each jar gets more attention than mass-produced alternatives.
Keto and Dietary Compatibility
For keto followers, the macros on pure cashew butter are solid. One tablespoon provides healthy fats with minimal carbs. The absence of any added ingredients means you can track your macros precisely without surprises from hidden sugars or oils.
7. Kevala Cashew Butter – Clean and Classic
Kevala Cashew Butter – Glass Jar 12 oz, Natural Peanut Butter Substitute
Size: 12 oz
No additives
Non-GMO verified
Glass jar packaging
Pros
- Completely clean label with zero additives
- Non-GMO Project verified
- Vegan and dairy-free in peanut-free facility
- Premium glass jar for freshness
Cons
- Dry-roasted only with no raw option
- 12 oz size is smaller than some competitors
Kevala has been around long enough to earn a loyal following, and after testing their cashew butter I understand why. The product is straightforward and dependable. Dry-roasted cashews, nothing else, in a quality glass jar that keeps the butter fresh longer than plastic.
The glass jar packaging is worth highlighting. Glass does not leach chemicals, preserves flavor better, and is fully recyclable. Several brands on this list use plastic, so Kevala stands out for users who prefer glass for food storage and environmental reasons.
With 634 reviews and a 4.4-star average, Kevala sits comfortably in the middle of the pack for ratings but near the top for ingredient purity. The peanut-free facility certification adds allergy safety that many buyers specifically seek out when shopping for nut alternatives.
I found the dry-roasted flavor to be pronounced and satisfying. It has a toasty depth that raw cashew butters lack. If you are someone who prefers the taste of roasted nuts over raw, Kevala delivers that flavor profile without any added oils or salt.
Glass Jar Versus Plastic
Beyond aesthetics, glass packaging serves a practical purpose. It prevents the slight plastic taste that can transfer to nut butters stored in cheap containers. Glass is also better for the environment since it can be recycled indefinitely without losing quality. Kevala and Once Again are the two glass-jar brands on this list.
Peanut-Free Facility Benefits
For schools, camps, and allergy-sensitive environments, peanut-free certification is essential. Kevala processes in a dedicated peanut-free facility, making it safe for those with peanut allergies. This is the kind of detail that matters enormously to the right buyer.
8. Fix and Fogg Creamy Cashew Butter – New Zealand Favorite
Fix & Fogg Creamy Cashew Butter Spread — New Zealand Made – 10 oz, 1 Pack
Size: 10 oz
Cashews and sea salt
B Corp certified
Family owned since 2014
Pros
- Simple two-ingredient recipe with sea salt
- B Corp certified for social and environmental standards
- Silky smooth texture that is highly versatile
- Family-owned company from New Zealand
Cons
- Natural separation requires stirring
- Only 10 oz jar is the smallest on this list
Fix and Fogg brings something different to the table. This New Zealand-based company adds a touch of sea salt to their cashew butter, and that single addition transforms the flavor. The salt amplifies the natural sweetness of the cashews in a way that unsalted versions simply cannot match.
The B Corp certification is a meaningful credential. It means the company meets rigorous standards for social and environmental performance, accountability, and transparency. For consumers who vote with their dollars, this certification signals a company doing business the right way.
At 10 ounces, this is the smallest jar on our list. The price per ounce is on the higher side. However, the quality of ingredients and the company ethos may justify the cost for buyers who prioritize ethical sourcing and small-batch craftsmanship over volume.
The review base is still growing at 54 reviews with a 4.2-star average. Fix and Fogg is relatively new to the Amazon marketplace compared to established brands like Artisana or 365. The lower review count means fewer data points, but the early feedback is largely positive.
The Sea Salt Difference
Adding sea salt to nut butter is a simple technique that professional chefs use to enhance flavor. If you have ever felt that unsalted cashew butter tastes flat or one-dimensional, Fix and Fogg solves that problem. The salt is subtle, not overpowering, and it rounds out the flavor beautifully.
Ethical and Environmental Standards
B Corp certification goes beyond organic or non-GMO labels. It evaluates the entire company on governance, workers, community, and environmental impact. Fix and Fogg also carries Non-GMO Project verification, making it a strong choice for ethically minded consumers.
9. Once Again Organic Creamy Cashew Butter – Ethically Sourced
Once Again Organic Creamy Cashew Butter, 16oz – Unsweetened – USDA Organic, Gluten free Certified, Vegan, Kosher, Peanut Free – Glass Jar… (1 Jar)
Size: 16 oz
USDA Organic
Peanut-free facility
Recyclable glass jar
Pros
- USDA Organic
- gluten-free
- vegan
- and kosher certifications
- Peanut-free facility for allergy safety
- Ethically sourced cashews with fair labor practices
- Recyclable glass jar packaging
Cons
- Contains 5 to 8 percent expeller-pressed sunflower oil
- Not eligible for Amazon Prime shipping
Once Again is an employee-owned company that has been making nut butters since 1976. Their cashew butter carries an impressive list of certifications: USDA Organic, gluten-free, vegan, and kosher. They clearly take their quality and ethical standards seriously.
The main difference with Once Again is the addition of expeller-pressed sunflower oil at 5 to 8 percent of the formula. This is added to improve spreadability and reduce separation. Some purists may prefer single-ingredient options, but the sunflower oil does make the butter easier to use straight from the fridge.
The glass jar is a nice touch for freshness and sustainability. Once Again is one of only two brands on this list that uses glass packaging. The recyclable jar appeals to environmentally conscious buyers who want to reduce plastic waste.
Forum users consistently mention Once Again as a reliable choice. The 4.3-star average across 325 reviews reflects a solid product with some mixed feedback, likely related to the sunflower oil addition. It ranks number 39 in the cashew butter bestseller category.
Understanding the Sunflower Oil Addition
The 5 to 8 percent sunflower oil is not a filler. It is expeller-pressed, which means it is extracted without chemical solvents. The oil improves texture and prevents the cashew butter from drying out. This makes Once Again one of the easiest cashew butters to spread cold, which many users appreciate.
Employee Ownership and Ethics
Once Again is an employee-owned company, which means the workers have a stake in the business. They source cashews ethically and prioritize fair labor practices. For buyers who consider corporate structure when making purchasing decisions, this is a brand worth supporting.
10. Maisie Janes Organic Creamy Cashew Butter – Family Farm Quality
Maisie Janes Organic Creamy Cashew Butter, 12 OZ
Size: 12 oz
USDA Organic
Kosher and non-GMO
Family-owned farm
Pros
- USDA Organic certified cashews
- Family-owned farm with direct sourcing
- Kosher
- non-GMO
- and vegan certified
- Gluten-free for dietary restrictions
Cons
- Lower 4.2 star rating with some negative reviews
- Not eligible for Amazon Prime
Maisie Jane’s comes from a family-owned farm in California that has been growing and processing nuts for generations. Their organic creamy cashew butter reflects their farming roots with simple, clean ingredients and a focus on quality from tree to jar.
The certifications are solid: USDA Organic, kosher, non-GMO, vegan, and gluten-free. This covers virtually every dietary requirement a buyer might have. For households with mixed dietary needs, having one product that checks all these boxes is convenient.
I found the texture slightly thicker than some competitors, which some buyers love and others find less spreadable. The flavor is pure cashew with a pleasant, natural sweetness. It works well in both sweet and savory applications.
The 4.2-star average is the lowest on this list, and about 9 percent of reviews are one-star. Looking at the negative reviews, complaints center around texture inconsistency and oil separation. This is worth noting if you are sensitive to those issues. However, 69 percent of reviewers still give it five stars, so the majority experience is positive.
Farm-to-Jar Transparency
Maisie Jane’s controls the process from their own orchards to the finished product. This vertical integration means they can guarantee quality at every step. For buyers who value knowing where their food comes from, this family farm model offers a level of transparency that larger brands cannot match.
Managing Texture Expectations
The thicker texture of this cashew butter makes it excellent for baking and cooking where you want the butter to hold its shape. If you find it too stiff for spreading, try warming it slightly in the microwave for 10 seconds. This softens it without separating the oils.
Buying Guide: How to Choose the Best Cashew Butter?
Choosing the right cashew butter comes down to understanding what matters most to you. The best cashew butters share some common traits, but personal preferences around texture, flavor, ingredients, and budget will determine which jar is right for your kitchen.
Ingredients: Fewer Is Better
The best cashew butters contain just one or two ingredients. Look for jars that list cashews as the primary or only ingredient. Some brands add a small amount of sea salt for flavor, which is perfectly fine. Avoid products with hydrogenated oils, added sugars, or artificial preservatives if you want the cleanest option.
Single-ingredient cashew butters will separate naturally because they contain no stabilizers. This is normal and actually a sign of quality. Brands like Once Again add a small percentage of sunflower oil to reduce separation, which is a reasonable compromise if stirring bothers you.
Raw Versus Roasted: Understanding the Difference
Raw cashew butter has a lighter, sweeter, and more delicate flavor. The natural sweetness of the cashews shines through without any roasting interference. Artisana Organics and Jiva Organics are excellent raw options that preserve this bright flavor profile.
Roasted cashew butter has a deeper, toastier, and more complex taste. The dry-roasting process brings out nutty caramel notes that many people prefer. Octonuts, Kevala, and Georgia Grinders all use roasted cashews to achieve this richer flavor. There is no wrong choice here, just personal preference.
Texture and Stir-Ability
Texture is one of the most discussed aspects of cashew butter in online forums. Users frequently complain about products that are too gritty, too runny, or impossible to stir. The creamiest options on our list are Georgia Grinders and Octonuts, both of which achieve a velvety consistency.
Stir-ability matters because natural separation is inevitable in quality cashew butter. Brands that leave extra headspace in the jar, like 365 by Whole Foods, make stirring easier and less messy. Pro tip: store the jar upside down for a day before opening to let gravity help redistribute the oil.
Organic Certification: Is It Worth It?
USDA Organic certification guarantees that the cashews were grown without synthetic pesticides or fertilizers. Brands like Artisana, Jiva Organics, Once Again, and Maisie Jane’s all carry this certification. If organic sourcing matters to you for health or environmental reasons, these are your best bets.
Non-organic brands like Octonuts and Spread The Love still offer clean ingredient lists without additives. The choice between organic and conventional depends on your priorities and budget. Both can deliver excellent quality and taste.
Packaging: Glass Versus Plastic
Glass jars preserve flavor better and are infinitely recyclable. Kevala and Once Again use glass packaging, which some consumers prefer for both taste and environmental reasons. Plastic jars are lighter, less breakable, and often more affordable. Neither option affects the quality of the butter inside.
Storage Tips for Maximum Freshness
Cashew butter should be stored in a cool, dry place before opening. After opening, refrigeration extends shelf life significantly. Natural cashew butter without preservatives will last about three months in the pantry and up to six months refrigerated. Always stir well before each use if it has been sitting.
If your cashew butter tastes rancid, it has likely been exposed to heat or light for too long. Rancidity is caused by oxidation of the natural oils. To prevent this, keep opened jars sealed tightly and away from direct sunlight. Glass jars offer slightly better protection against flavor degradation over time.
Price Per Ounce: Getting the Best Value
When comparing prices, always calculate cost per ounce rather than looking at the total jar price. A 16-ounce jar that costs more upfront may actually be cheaper per ounce than a 12-ounce jar at a lower sticker price. The 365 by Whole Foods brand offers the best value per ounce on this list.
Premium brands like Georgia Grinders and Jiva Organics cost more per ounce but deliver superior quality, texture, or certifications. Decide what matters most to you and calculate accordingly. For daily users who go through a jar a month, the per-ounce calculation can reveal significant savings over time.
FAQs
Is cashew butter healthier than peanut butter?
Cashew butter and peanut butter each have different nutritional strengths. Cashew butter contains more copper, iron, and magnesium per serving, while peanut butter generally provides more protein. Cashew butter is naturally sweeter and creamier, and it is safe for people with peanut allergies. Both are nutritious options when you choose brands with no added sugar or hydrogenated oils.
What is the healthiest brand of nut butter?
The healthiest cashew butter brands are those with a single ingredient and no additives. Artisana Organics Raw Cashew Butter, Jiva Organics Raw Organic Cashew Butter, and Octonuts Creamy Cashew Butter all contain only pure cashews. These brands offer maximum nutritional value with zero added sugars, oils, or preservatives.
Which cashew butter brand is best?
Based on our testing, Georgia Grinders Creamy Cashew Butter is the best overall pick with its 4.9-star rating and velvety texture. For best value, the 365 by Whole Foods Creamy Cashew Butter delivers quality at a budget-friendly price. Artisana Organics is the top choice for raw and organic purists.
Why does cashew butter sometimes taste rancid?
Rancid taste in cashew butter is caused by oxidation of the natural oils when exposed to heat, light, or air for extended periods. To prevent rancidity, store opened jars in the refrigerator, keep them tightly sealed, and consume within three to six months. Glass jars provide better protection against flavor degradation than plastic.
How should I store cashew butter?
Store unopened cashew butter in a cool, dry pantry away from direct sunlight. After opening, refrigerate the jar to extend freshness up to six months. Always stir natural cashew butter before use since oil separation is normal. Storing the jar upside down before opening helps redistribute separated oils naturally.
Final Thoughts on the Best Cashew Butters
Finding the best cashew butters comes down to matching a brand to your personal taste, budget, and dietary needs. Georgia Grinders takes the top spot for its unmatched texture and flavor. The 365 by Whole Foods option wins on value. And Artisana Organics remains the benchmark for raw, organic quality.
Each of the 10 brands on this list offers something worth trying. Whether you want a simple single-ingredient spread, a sea-salt-enhanced treat, or a peanut-free option for allergy safety, there is a jar here for you. The cashew butter market has grown significantly in 2026, and these brands represent the cream of the crop.