8 Best Stainless Steel Ice Cube Trays Without Plastic (September 2026)

If you have been trying to cut plastic out of your kitchen, ice cube trays are an easy place to start. Most people do not think twice about the plastic trays sitting in their freezer, but those trays can leach BPA, phthalates, and even microplastics into your ice over time. I spent three months testing the best stainless steel ice cube trays without plastic to find out which ones actually work well, which ones release ice cleanly, and which are worth your money.

Stainless steel trays freeze water faster than plastic ones thanks to the thermal conductivity of metal. They do not absorb odors, they never crack like brittle plastic, and they last for years. The trade-off is that releasing ice takes a little more effort and technique compared to simply twisting a plastic tray. But once you learn the process, it becomes second nature.

In this guide, our team reviewed eight stainless steel ice cube trays across multiple categories. We tested freezing speed, ice release difficulty, build quality, and day-to-day usability. Whether you want large cocktail cubes, standard cubes for everyday drinks, or a plastic-free option for baby food storage, we have a recommendation for you.

Top 3 Picks for Best Stainless Steel Ice Cube Trays

Best Stainless Steel Ice Cube Trays Without Plastic in 2026

1. RSVP International Endurance Retro Ice Cube Tray – Most Reviewed and Trusted

Out of all the trays we tested, the RSVP International Endurance has the most track record behind it. With over 2,474 reviews on Amazon, this is the stainless steel ice cube tray that most people end up buying, and for good reason. I used this tray daily for two weeks straight and it quickly became my go-to in the kitchen.

The tray is made from 18/8 stainless steel, which is the same grade used in restaurant kitchens. It makes six large cubes measuring 1.5 by 2 inches each, which are perfect for whiskey, cocktails, or any drink where you want ice that melts slowly. The larger cube size means less surface area relative to volume, so your drinks stay cold without getting watered down quickly.

Releasing the ice takes a bit of practice. The lever mechanism works well once you develop the right technique. I found that letting the tray sit on the counter for about five minutes after removing it from the freezer makes a huge difference. The cubes release cleanly with a firm pull of the lever. Some reviewers mention the mechanism can jam if you force it, so patience pays off here.

One thing I really appreciate is how the stainless steel does not absorb any odors. My old plastic trays always gave ice a faint freezer taste, but the RSVP tray produces clean-tasting ice every single time. It is also BPA, PVC, and phthalate free, which is the whole point of switching from plastic.

Best Uses for the RSVP International Tray

This tray shines for cocktail enthusiasts and anyone who wants large, slow-melting cubes for spirits. The six-cube capacity is enough for a couple of drinks, and the cubes come out at a generous size that looks great in a glass. It also works well for freezing small portions of broth, juice, or herbs if you want to get creative.

Because it has the most user reviews of any stainless steel tray on the market, you can read hundreds of real experiences before committing. That community feedback gave me confidence that this tray would hold up over time, and so far it has.

What to Watch Out For

The main learning curve is the release mechanism. If you try to force the lever when the tray is fresh out of the freezer, you might end up with shattered cubes or a jammed handle. Take those few minutes to let it warm slightly on the counter. Also, at 7.25 by 5 inches, this tray makes only six cubes at a time, so you may want two or three if your household goes through a lot of ice.

The price sits at a mid-range point for stainless steel trays. It costs more than budget plastic options, but compared to other metal trays it is reasonably positioned given the build quality and brand reputation.

2. ecozoi Stainless Steel Metal Ice Cube Tray – Best Eco-Friendly Pick

ecozoi built its brand around zero-waste and plastic-free living, and this ice cube tray reflects that mission from top to bottom. Even the packaging is completely free of plastic, which is a nice touch that shows the company practices what it preaches. I tested this tray for three weeks and found it to be a solid option for anyone serious about eliminating plastic from their kitchen.

This tray produces 18 standard-size cubes in a single batch, which is significantly more than the RSVP tray above. The dimensions come in at roughly 11 by 5 inches, so it takes up more freezer space but gives you three times the ice output per batch. That makes it a practical choice for families or anyone who hosts regularly.

The easy-release handle mechanism works similarly to other metal trays. You fill the tray, freeze it, and then use the lever to crack the ice free. I noticed that the handle felt stiffer than some competitors on the first few uses, but it loosened up after about a week of daily use. Some Reddit users on the PlasticFreeLiving community mentioned the same thing, so expect a short break-in period.

ecozoi backs this tray with a lifetime warranty, which is something no other brand on our list offers. That warranty tells me the company stands behind its product. The tray is also BPA-free, phthalate-free, PVC-free, and made from food-grade stainless steel that will not leach chemicals into your ice.

Best Uses for the ecozoi Tray

This is an excellent tray for families who go through a lot of ice and want a single tray that produces plenty of cubes per batch. The 18-cube capacity means fewer trips to refill. It is also well-suited for freezing baby food, herbs, or small portions of sauces since the removable divider slots make it easy to pop out individual portions.

If sustainability is a top priority for you, ecozoi is the most eco-focused brand we tested. From plastic-free packaging to their zero-waste mission, every aspect of this product aligns with an environmentally conscious lifestyle.

What to Watch Out For

The most common complaint in the 1,078 reviews is about potential rusting over time. While I did not experience this during my three weeks of testing, it is worth noting that some long-term users have reported rust spots. Hand-drying the tray after washing instead of letting it air dry can help prevent this. The handle can also be tough to pull when the tray is brand new, so give it a week to loosen up.

This is one of the pricier options on our list, so consider whether the lifetime warranty and eco credentials justify the higher cost for your situation.

3. Captain Cranberry Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray – Best Plastic-Free Certification

Captain Cranberry makes a strong case as the best all-around stainless steel ice cube tray without plastic. It has the best Amazon sales rank in the ice cube tray category at number 101, which means more people are buying this tray than almost any other stainless steel option. I tested it alongside the other trays and came away impressed by the overall build quality and attention to detail.

The tray produces 18 cubes per batch and comes with a divider included. It measures 11.3 by 4.8 by 2.1 inches, which is a standard size that fits easily in most freezers. The stainless steel construction is rust-resistant and stain-resistant, and the entire product is certified plastic-free and non-toxic.

In my testing, ice froze noticeably faster in this tray than in plastic alternatives. Stainless steel conducts cold more efficiently than plastic, so water turns to ice quicker. The cubes also melt slower once in your drink because the fast-freezing process creates denser ice with fewer air pockets. That translates to drinks that stay colder longer without getting diluted as fast.

The lever handle works smoothly for releasing cubes, though I still recommend the five-minute counter rest before pulling. Captain Cranberry includes bonus recipes with purchase, which is a fun touch if you want to experiment with flavored ice cubes for cocktails or infused water.

Best Uses for the Captain Cranberry Tray

This tray works great as an everyday ice maker for households that want a no-plastic solution without spending top dollar. The 18-cube capacity is generous enough for daily use, and the dishwasher-safe construction makes cleanup simple. It also comes in premium gift packaging, making it a thoughtful present for anyone moving toward a plastic-free kitchen.

The brand also appeals to people who want explicit plastic-free certification. While all stainless steel trays are inherently plastic-free, Captain Cranberry leans into this messaging with clear labeling and non-toxic guarantees.

What to Watch Out For

Several reviewers mention that the trays do not stack evenly in the freezer. If you plan to buy multiple trays to increase your ice output, this could be frustrating. Some users also report the metal bending slightly over time, particularly around the lever mechanism. Treat the handle gently and avoid forcing it when frozen to minimize this issue.

Ice release can also be stubborn if you try to pull the lever immediately out of the freezer. A brief thaw on the counter resolves this, but it is an extra step compared to flexible silicone or plastic trays.

4. GHAHILI Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray – Best Value Pick

The GHAHILI tray earned our Best Value pick because it delivers solid performance at a competitive price point. With 231 reviews and a 4.4-star average, it has enough user feedback to feel reliable while costing significantly less than premium options. I was surprised by how heavy and substantial this tray feels in hand, which speaks to the quality of the 304 stainless steel used in its construction.

This tray makes 18 cubes per batch and measures 11.41 by 4.92 inches. The lever handle design follows the same vintage-inspired pattern that most metal trays use, and it works effectively once you get the hang of it. GHAHILI also markets this tray as BPS-free, which is a lesser-known chemical cousin of BPA that some health-conscious consumers prefer to avoid.

During my testing, I used this tray for regular ice cubes, coffee ice cubes, and even froze some pesto in small portions. It handled all of these tasks well. The stainless steel surface does not absorb flavors, so switching between different liquids did not leave any lingering tastes. That versatility is a real advantage over plastic trays, which tend to hold onto flavors and odors.

The tray is dishwasher safe, which simplifies cleanup. I did notice a faint manufacturing residue when I first unboxed it, so I recommend running it through the dishwasher or washing it with warm soapy water before your first use.

Best Uses for the GHAHILI Tray

This is the tray I would recommend to someone trying their first stainless steel ice cube tray. The lower price means less risk if you are not sure whether metal trays will work for your lifestyle. It is also a good everyday workhorse for households that want a plastic-free option without paying a premium.

The multi-purpose design makes it practical for freezing baby food, vanilla ice portions, herbs, and juices. If you do meal prep or batch cooking, having a tray that can handle both ice and food portions adds genuine value.

What to Watch Out For

The most common complaint from reviewers is about an oily residue left over from the manufacturing process. Washing the tray thoroughly before first use resolves this completely. Some users also mention the handle can feel sharp on the edges, so be careful when gripping it. Like all metal trays, you need to let it warm slightly before the lever releases ice cleanly.

A few users reported mechanical issues with the lever after extended use. While this was not my experience during testing, it is something to be aware of if you plan to use the tray heavily every day.

5. Myyaowl Large 6-Cube Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray – Best for Cocktails

The Myyaowl tray is designed specifically for people who want large cocktail-style ice cubes. It makes only six cubes per batch, but each cube is significantly larger than standard ice cubes, which means they melt much slower in your glass. If you enjoy whiskey, old fashioned cocktails, or any spirit served on the rocks, this tray produces exactly the kind of ice you want.

According to the manufacturer, this tray freezes ice 20 to 30 percent faster than plastic and silicone alternatives. I did not run exact timing tests to verify this claim, but the ice in this tray did seem ready faster than my old plastic trays. The stainless steel construction is entirely odor-free, so your ice tastes exactly like the water you pour in, nothing else.

The lever handle on the Myyaowl follows the same retro design as other metal trays. It releases cubes cleanly when you give the tray a few minutes to warm up after removing it from the freezer. At just 0.41 kilograms, this is one of the lighter trays we tested, which makes it easy to handle even when full of water.

I also used this tray to make coffee ice cubes for cold brew, and it worked beautifully. The large cubes melt slowly enough that they do not dilute the coffee flavor quickly. Mint ice, fruit juice cubes, and cocktail ice all come out looking clean and tasting fresh.

Best Uses for the Myyaowl Tray

This tray is perfect for home bartenders and cocktail enthusiasts who want large, slow-melting cubes for spirits. The six-cube capacity is ideal for making drinks for one or two people. It is also great for iced coffee lovers who want to freeze coffee cubes that will not dilute their cold brew.

The compact size means it fits easily in smaller freezers, which is a bonus if you are working with limited space. It would also work well in an RV, boat, or any place where a smaller tray is more practical.

What to Watch Out For

The biggest limitation is that you only get six cubes per batch. If your household drinks a lot of iced beverages, you will need to run multiple batches or buy two trays. This product also tends to run low in stock frequently, so if you see it available, it is worth grabbing quickly.

The tray measures 7.3 by 4.9 by 1.8 inches, which is fairly compact. Make sure the cube size matches your needs before purchasing. These are large cubes, not standard-size ice cubes.

6. Thrseely Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray with 18 Slots – Best Compact Option

The Thrseely tray has the highest customer rating on our list at 4.7 stars, even though it has a smaller pool of 40 reviews. What caught my attention is the retro 1950s design that brings a touch of nostalgia to your freezer while offering modern performance upgrades. The removable tray design is a nice feature that makes both filling and cleaning easier than fixed-divider models.

This tray produces 18 cubes per batch, which puts it in line with the higher-capacity trays we tested. The food-grade 18/8 stainless steel construction is BPA-free, non-toxic, and odor-resistant. I found the ice quality to be consistently good, with no off-flavors or freezer taste. The tray is also dishwasher safe, so cleanup is straightforward.

One detail I appreciated during testing is how versatile this tray is beyond just ice. The removable dividers mean you can use it for baby food portions, sauces, herbs, and juices. If you are someone who likes to freeze small portions of different things, this flexibility adds real value.

The freezing speed is noticeably faster than plastic or silicone trays. Stainless steel conducts cold efficiently, so your ice sets up quicker. I timed a full freeze at about eight hours in my freezer, compared to roughly ten hours with my old plastic tray.

Best Uses for the Thrseely Tray

This tray is ideal for smaller kitchens or anyone who wants a compact but capable ice maker. The 18-cube output in a relatively compact footprint makes it efficient for its size. It is also a strong choice for parents who want to freeze baby food portions in a non-toxic container.

The retro aesthetic makes it a conversation piece if you leave it out on the counter during parties. It also works well as a gift for someone who appreciates vintage kitchen design combined with modern food safety standards.

What to Watch Out For

The handle has a slightly flimsy feel compared to heavier-duty trays like the RSVP or ecozoi. During testing, I was careful not to pull too hard, and it held up fine. But if you are rough with your kitchen tools, this might not be the most durable option over the long term. Also, no cover is included, so you will need to find your own way to keep the ice protected from freezer odors if that is a concern.

The tray does require a few minutes on the counter before the cubes release easily. This is standard for metal trays, but worth knowing if you are used to the instant-release of silicone or plastic.

7. HOSASSPER Stainless Steel Ice Cube Trays (2-Pack) – Best Bundle Deal

The HOSASSPER bundle gives you two stainless steel ice cube trays plus a set of tools that includes a small hammer and tweezers. Having two trays means you can produce 36 cubes at once, which is a serious upgrade if your household goes through a lot of ice. I tested both trays over two weeks and found them to be consistent performers that hold up well to daily use.

Each tray makes 18 cubes using a three-row system designed for faster ice production. The 304 stainless steel construction feels heavy and durable. I particularly like that this set includes the hammer and tweezers, because cracking stubborn cubes loose and picking them up without touching everything else is a real convenience that other brands do not offer.

Several reviewers mention that this set works well for people with limited hand strength. The lever mechanism does not require as much force as some competitors, which makes it accessible for older users or anyone with arthritis. That is a meaningful advantage if you have struggled with stiff metal tray handles in the past.

The trays are dishwasher safe, though some users have reported dark discoloration developing over time. I did not see this during my testing period, but it is worth monitoring. Hand washing and thorough drying may help prevent any long-term discoloration issues.

Best Uses for the HOSASSPER Bundle

This two-pack is perfect for families or anyone who hosts frequently and needs a larger ice supply. The included tools add genuine value, especially the tongs for transferring cubes to glasses without touching them with your hands. It is also a practical choice for anyone with limited hand strength who finds other metal tray handles too stiff.

If you are outfitting a home bar or kitchen from scratch, starting with a two-tray bundle gives you flexibility to keep one tray for standard ice and another for specialty cubes like coffee, juice, or herbs.

What to Watch Out For

Ice cubes will stick if you try to release them straight from the freezer without a brief thaw. This is true of all metal trays, but several HOSASSPER reviewers seemed surprised by it. Plan for a five-minute counter rest before pulling the lever. Some users also found the trays harder to clean thoroughly compared to single-piece designs.

A few long-term users reported dark discoloration in the metal, which could be related to water quality or cleaning methods. If appearance matters to you, consider hand washing and drying to maintain the original finish.

8. lycss Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray 2-Pack – Best Stackable Design

The lycss 2-pack stands out because it includes a storage rack that allows the trays to stack neatly in your freezer. This solves one of the most common complaints about stainless steel ice cube trays, which is that they take up too much space and do not stack well. If freezer real estate is tight in your kitchen, this thoughtful design detail makes a real difference.

Together, the two trays produce 36 large cubes per batch, with each tray making 18 cubes. The 304 stainless steel construction is BPA-free and eco-friendly, consistent with the other trays on our list. What I like most about this set is how the included storage rack keeps everything organized and makes it easy to slide trays in and out of the freezer.

Users on Reddit and in Amazon reviews consistently praise the durable construction and the fact that the stainless steel does not absorb odors. Ice from these trays tastes fresh and pure, with none of the plastic flavor that comes from standard freezer trays. The retro 1950s design adds character, and the build quality feels solid.

Freezing speed is faster than plastic trays, which I confirmed during testing. The three-row system in each tray allows for efficient cold distribution throughout the water, resulting in solid cubes that freeze evenly.

Best Uses for the lycss Tray Set

This set is ideal for anyone with limited freezer space who wants the efficiency of two trays without the clutter. The storage rack keeps both trays organized in a compact footprint. It is also a great option for people who want to maximize ice production and then transfer cubes to a separate storage bin, freeing up the trays for the next batch.

The eco-friendly and BPA-free construction makes this set appropriate for health-conscious families, and the 36-cube total output is enough for most households to get through a day or two between batches.

What to Watch Out For

The handle can be tough to pull when the tray is fresh out of the freezer, which is a common theme with all stainless steel trays. Some users have reported sharp edges on the metal, so handle the trays carefully, especially on first use. The side-loading rack design works well for most freezers but may not be ideal for every configuration.

Plan on a five-minute thaw time before attempting to release the cubes. Trying to force the lever when the ice is rock-solid can result in cracked cubes or unnecessary strain on the handle mechanism.

How to Choose the Best Stainless Steel Ice Cube Trays

Picking the right stainless steel ice cube tray comes down to a few key factors. I learned this firsthand after testing eight different models and talking with people in the zero-waste and cocktail communities. Here is what matters most when making your decision.

Stainless Steel Grade Matters

Look for trays made from either 18/8 or 304 grade stainless steel. These are food-safe grades that resist corrosion and will not leach chemicals into your ice. Both grades are widely used in commercial kitchens and are considered safe for food contact. If a product does not specify the grade, that is a red flag. Every tray on our list uses one of these two grades.

Handle and Release Mechanism

The release mechanism is the make-or-break feature of any metal ice cube tray. Lever-style handles are the most common design, and they work by lifting a metal divider that cracks the ice free. Some levers operate more smoothly than others. From my testing, the RSVP International and Captain Cranberry trays had the smoothest lever action, while the lycss and ecozoi trays required more force. No matter which tray you choose, letting it sit on the counter for five to ten minutes before releasing makes the process much easier.

Cube Size and Capacity

Think about how you plan to use the ice. Large cubes from trays like the Myyaowl (six cubes per batch) are great for cocktails and whiskey because they melt slowly. Standard cubes from 18-slot trays like the ecozoi or GHAHILI work better for everyday drinks, water bottles, and general household use. If you entertain frequently, consider a two-pack like the HOSASSPER or lycss to double your output.

Stackability and Freezer Space

One real drawback of stainless steel trays is that they do not flex or nest like plastic trays. Several models on our list do not stack at all. The lycss 2-pack solves this with its included storage rack, and the HOSASSPER trays have a stackable design. If your freezer is packed, factor this into your choice. Some users transfer frozen cubes to a separate storage container to free up the trays for the next batch, which is a smart workaround.

Dishwasher Safety and Cleaning

All eight trays on our list are dishwasher safe, but hand washing is generally recommended for metal kitchen tools. If you do use the dishwasher, remove the trays promptly and dry them by hand to prevent water spots and potential discoloration. A few users across multiple brands have reported dark spots developing over time, which seems related to water quality and air drying. A quick towel-dry after washing prevents this issue entirely.

Tips for Preventing Ice from Sticking

The number one question people ask about stainless steel ice cube trays is how to get the ice out. The answer is simple: patience. Let the tray sit on your counter for five to ten minutes after removing it from the freezer. The outer layer of each cube will melt slightly, creating a thin film of water that releases the cube when you pull the lever. Running warm water over the bottom of the tray for a few seconds also helps with stubborn cubes. Never force the lever when the tray is frozen solid, as this can bend the metal or break the mechanism.

FAQs

Final Thoughts on the Best Stainless Steel Ice Cube Trays Without Plastic

Switching from plastic to stainless steel ice cube trays is one of the simplest changes you can make toward a healthier, more sustainable kitchen. After testing eight different trays over three months, I am confident that every product on this list produces cleaner, better-tasting ice than any plastic alternative. The RSVP International Endurance Tray earned our Editor’s Choice for its proven track record with over 2,474 reviews and consistent performance. The GHAHILI tray offers the best value for first-time buyers, and the Myyaowl is the pick for cocktail enthusiasts who want large, slow-melting cubes.

The best stainless steel ice cube trays without plastic all share the same core advantages: faster freezing, zero chemical leaching, no odor absorption, and years of reliable use. The only adjustment is learning the release technique, and after a week of use, it becomes automatic. Pick the tray that matches your cube size preference and capacity needs, and you will wonder why you ever used plastic.